How important is conducting technique?


I’ve been wondering recently about the importance of the physical part of what a conductor does. There are certainly many very renowned musicians with no formal training who are making careers out of conducting (or at least substantially supplementing their usual work with guest conducting.) In many cases these are chamber orchestras or baroque/classical music (often music composed at a time when the conductor as we know him today had yet to become a permanent fixture at the front of the orchestra.) Now I am ruling out poor musicians altogether. I want to know if a conductor can be successful relying on his or her musical mind, without any substantial training in the physical aspects of the task. Does there come a point when a great musician’s lack of training can actually be a detriment on the podium that cannot be overcome by a great musical mind, or even by just a deep passion for the music.

Valery Gergiev says in this documentary :

“For [a] conductor this is a question of how to use his personality and his education… the strength of his character… so that the musicians will be very quickly involved of the atmosphere of the piece. It doesn’t really matter how well you move with your hands. It should be in your face, it should be in your expression. “

Certainly this is true. I find in general that most of what a conductor does is in what he says and how he acts in rehearsal. Gergiev is very intense on the podium (90% of what is available to see him conduct on video is Shostakovich, Prokofiev and other heavy stuff) and it doesn’t matter if he conducts with a toothpick. And not every conductor is Gergiev either. I personally have worked with conductors who says amazing, insightful and inspiring things in a rehearsal, only to have their lack of physical conducting ability undo a lot of that work once they get onto the podium in a performance.

A counterpoint to Gergiev would be Pierre Boulez**. I can honestly say I have no idea if Boulez had any serious formal training as a conductor, but he certainly has had a career that can hardly be touched. As can be seen below Boulez doesn’t let himself appear to be physically affected by the music. Save for an occasional leaning forward for emphasis, he just stands there and provides a simple, clear beat while the music swirls around him as if he’s surrounded by a force field.

Watching more of Boulez conduct lately I have come to appreciate what a clear ictus, unaffected by other body movement can mean for the quality of a performance. One thing that I see many conductors of various experience do which drives me crazy is when conducting in one, the downbeat gradually morphs into an upward motion (or worse yet, a spastic circle, as if wrangling cattle with a lasso) with no clear beginning or end. Any reader who has worked with Boulez – please share some insight into his rehearsal style in the comments, that will help me greatly with a follow up post about conductors and rehearsal style.

Finally, I’d like to talk about one phenomenon that I find strange: orchestras that play way behind the conductors beat, (or perhaps rather, conductors who insist the orchestra plays way behind their beat.) The Philadelphia Orchestra is well known for this. Except for one individual, on two isolated occasions, I have never really worked in this manner. I assume that once you’re used to it it’s not really any more difficult that what I am accustomed to, however, at this point watching it actually happen is still slightly mind boggling. How do you start anything?

And then there’s Carlos Kleiber…

I don’t really understand how some of that is meant to be interpreted, and yet he was one of the 20th Century’s preeminent conductors, so he was clearly doing something right.

** Boulez fans have to check out this post, and this post from Clownsilly


12 responses to “How important is conducting technique?

  1. I would love to see Kleiber’s reaction to those musicians (every orchestra has some) who demand to know “in what bar will you go into two?” and seriously can’t handle the complex mathematics of a fast four switching to a slow two.
    I knew a trumpet player once who couldn’t grasp a change from 3/8 into 12/8, where the eighth stayed constant.
    Speaking of trumpeters, Horvey worked with Boulez last summer – drop her an email!
    Check out this video of Furtwangler; zany!

    Hi Ryan,
    It seems like Furtwangler always had this weird stretched out marionette thing happening, check out this video from about 3 minutes:

    . Actually check it all out because it’s the rockingest Brahms 4 ever.

  2. Had you not ruled out poor musicians I’d have a great deal more to say. I think good stick technique is more necessary in less skilled orchestras. It also depends on how the orchestra is trained or what it is used to. My orchestra desperately needs a conductor with a good stick and a warm, loving personality and a strong tolerance for mediocrity and the ability to transform poor musicians into proper ones. Oh God do I need a new job.

  3. Pingback: Conducting continued « The Philharmonist

  4. robert berger

    Some famous conductors,such as Koussevitzky and Furtwangler were able to
    make great careers in spite of their faulty
    baton technique through sheer willpower
    and force of personality. The Great Conductors, by the late Harold C Schonberg,
    discusses this fact and is quite absorbing to read.

  5. Hi! I was surfing and found your blog post… nice! I love your blog. 🙂 Cheers! Sandra. R.

  6. Great, very stunning issue. I’m going to write about it also!

  7. Mr. George Bonsu

    most at times in children’s singing, adults normally do the conducting them selfs. how can you handle children’s choir within the range of 3 years to 12 years in the training of children conductors?

  8. isabella DiMera

    this has helped me really alot

  9. The other day, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iPad and
    tested to see if it can survive a 30 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now broken and she has 83 views.

    I know this is totally off topic but I had to share
    it with someone!

  10. Hi there, of course this post is really good and I have learned lot of things from it
    on the topic of blogging. thanks.

  11. Emeokoro Chukwuma Lazarus

    very insightful and educative

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s